Wondering where the best place to stay in the Florida Keys is? Whether you’ve never been to the Keys or frequent the region, it’s important to understand that there’s a home for every type of traveler in the Keys. From romantic couples resorts to family-friendly resort, there’s a spot waiting for you in the 100+ miles of the Keys.
Choosing the ideal place to stay in the Florida Keys can feel overwhelming because each area offers something completely different. In this guide, I’ll break down exactly where to stay in the Florida Keys based on your travel style, budget, and vacation goals.
Really, if you ask me, the best place to stay in the Florida Keys really depends on what you’re looking to get out of your trip. I’ve broken down some key recommendations (no pun intended) to help you narrow down the best spots for the vacation you envision. Let’s break them down.
Quick Answer: What Is the Best Place to Stay in the Florida Keys?
- Best Overall Hotel: Isla Bella Beach Resort
- Best Overall Luxury Resort: Playa Largo Resort & Spa
- Best Couples Resorts: The Bungalows Key Largo, Ombi Floating Bungalows
- Best Family Resorts: Baker’s Cay Resort, Havana Cabana Resort
- Best Sunset Resort: Ocean Key Resort & Spa
- Best Marina Resort: The Perry Hotel
- Best Family-Friendly Resort: Havana Cabana
How to Choose the Best Place to Stay in the Florida Keys
Before you start planning your stay, let’s first go over the simple basics of the different areas of the Keys.
- Key Largo: Closest to the mainland Florida, a great spot for first-time visitors and a great spot for water sports. More of a quieter, laid-back feel. This spot in the Keys is more accessible than those further south.
- Islamorada: This area caters to more luxury travelers and has a quieter atmosphere than other areas of the Keys.
- Marathon: Marathon marks the “mid-point” of the Keys, ideal for families with lots of resort options to choose from.
- Key West: Key West is the southernmost town in the Florida Keys, known for it’s walkability and “downtown” feel. Key West has a more lively nightlife scene and some incredible sunsets.
Once you’ve narrowed down the location you want to stay in, it’s time to decided which hotel is the best choice for your travel style. Check out some of my top recommendations below.
Best Place to Stay in the Keys for Families
A family trip to the Florida Keys is iconic. From tubing to scuba diving, there’s a lot to do to make amazing family memories. Two of my favorite choices for family-friendly hotels in the Florida Keys are Havana Cabana in Key West and Baker’s Cay Resort in Key Largo. Here’s why.
- Havana Cabana: Bright, colorful, fun, lively. Huge resort-style pool for families and outdoor games. Downtown shuttle for easy access.
- Baker’s Cay Resort: Dedicated kids activities, big pool with waterfall, shallow beaches, free included water sports
Best Resorts in the Florida Keys for Couples
The Florida Keys also attract lots of couples seeking a Caribbean-style vacation right in the U.S. From honeymoons to special occasions like anniversaries, the Keys have some pretty unique romantic spots. Some of my favorites include:
- Ombi Floating Bungalows, Key Largo: Spend a night or two out floating on these unique luxury floating bungalows. These are the only true floating bungalows in the U.S. and come with everything you need for a serene, unique experience.
- Bungalows Key Largo: Each couple stays in a private romantic bungalow. This is one of the U.S.’ only all-inclusive resorts and has a calm, wellness-focused feel to it. The all-inclusive set up at the Bungalows Key Largo includes food, beverage, and activities for each couple.
- Playa Largo Resort: This upscale resort in Key Largo has one of my favorite pools of all hotels in the Keys. They recently renovated their cabanas for a fresh, modern feel. This resort reminds me of a resort in the Caribbean islands.
Sunset & Sunrise Key West: Where to Stay to Watch
There’s about 100 country songs talking about Florida Keys sunset and sunrises — and for good reason. If you’re trying to catch the sunrise or sunset in Key West, check out a stay at Ocean Key. This luxury resort & spa faces the water near Mallory Square.
If you book the right room, you can get incredible sunset and sunrise views without having to even face the crowds downstairs. This was a real highlight of choosing this hotel on our recent trip to Key West.
Best Place to Stay in the Florida Keys - Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Is Key West the best place to stay in the Florida Keys?
A: Key West is a great option for your Florida Keys trip, but the best spot is one that meets your personal travel needs. Key West is a smart choice for travelers seeking an upbeat, lively atmosphere.
Q: Which Florida Key is best for families?
A: For families traveling to the Florida Keys for the first time, I recommend visiting Key Largo or Marathon. These areas have the most activities and water sports in the keys.
Q: Where should couples stay in the Florida Keys?
A: Ombi Floating Bungalows in Key Largo, Bungalows Key Largo and Playa Largo are popular resorts in the Keys for couples.
Q: What is the best time of year to visit the Florida Keys?
A: You can have a blast visiting the Florida Keys any time of the year but the winter months tend to be the best to go. Summer can be pretty hot, but still enjoyable if planned correctly.
Q: How many days do you need in the Florida Keys?
A: If you’re looking to get the most of your Florida Keys getaway, I’d recommend 3 to 6 days for the ideal vacation length.
Q: Where should I stay in the Florida Keys without a car?
A: The best walkable town in the Keys is Key West. You can get here and not need to move your car (or bring one) at all if you choose to stay in the downtown area.